Crime & LawAgree / DisagreeIntermediateHigh Frequency

Criminal Treatment

Prompt

Young people committing crimes should be treated the same as adults by the authorities. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

#juvenile justice#developmental differences#accountability#rehabilitation vs. punishment#age-based rights#neurobiology

Ready?

Write this essay in 40 minutes

Start

✨

Band 7 → 9 — Band 7 argues rehabilitation potential vs. punishment fairness; Band 9 integrates neuroscience (prefrontal cortex development through mid-20s), distinguishes crime severity and intent, and argues that the question isn't same treatment but whether the justice system's goal is punishment or rehabilitation—which should be universal, not age-based.

PRO

Essay #87 — part of the Pro library

The first 30 Task 2 essays are free. Upgrade to Pro to read this one plus the full Pro essay library.

Upgrade

Key concepts in this essay

adolescent brain development
culpability and intent
rehabilitation capacity
deterrence theory
proportionality

Pitfalls the model essay avoids

Ignoring developmental neuroscience showing adolescent brains differ significantly in impulse control and judgment; treating as simple maturity argument rather than cognitive science
Conflating severity of crime with age appropriateness (minor shoplifting vs. violent crime require different analysis)
Overlooking that punishment severity is separate from the question of same judicial treatment (can be tried as adult but in juvenile system)

Next in Crime & Law

See all →